Dear Commission, Your motion is fine, but only addresses half the problem.
The history of factual basis stakeholders is longer than most imagine. It started a few years back in Glassell Park, when a local church wanted to put up a large video pole sign and was rebuffed by the GPNC. That church put together their own candidate slate and brought in all their congregation from outside the area to vote and successfully engineered a takeover of that Glassell Park Neighborhood council.
At that time, no one wanted to risk the political incorrectness of going after a local church, but last summer Jose Huizar and the Eagle Rock Neighborhood Council felt safe disenfranchising employees and owners of medical marijuana dispensaries, even though there was no city or state law prohibiting them at that time.
They said at that time these folks were not disenfranchised because they could still vote under the factual basis rules.
Eliminating factual basis stakeholders is a good thing, but your work is only half done, if the powerful and well connected can conspire to disenfranchise legitimate stakeholders they don’t like. Last year it was medical marijuana dispensary owners and their employees. Next year will it be massage parlor owners and their employees? After that, will it be auto body and mechanic shop owners and their employees? After that fast food joints that sell trans-fat cooked food, or sellers of sugary sodas over 16 ounces?
The ride down the slippery slope has started. Will anyone stand up for frowned upon, yet legitimate stakeholders? Or will it be you who is the next to be barred from voting in your neighborhood council because the powerful don’t like you or the group you associate with?
If you want to eliminate factual basis voters and candidates, fine. HOWEVER… you should also create new rules to protect legitimate voters from last minute “interpretations” by deputy city attorneys that disenfranchise legitimate stakeholders who are in opposition to their neighborhood council and City Councilperson… which is exactly what happened in Eagle Rock last October.
We citizens should not have to resort to expensive legal action to prevent this from happening next time. Please continue your work and correct this all-the-way.